Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer
##common.pageHeaderLogo.altText##

Commentary

Vol. 16 No. 1 (2018)

A Tale of Two Brains- Cortical localization and neurophysiology in the 19th and 20th century

DOI
https://doi.org/10.26443/mjm.v16i1.106
Submitted
March 10, 2018
Published
2018-07-06

Abstract

Introduction: Other authors have well described the importance of experimental physiology in the development of brain sciences and the individual discoveries of the founding fathers of modern neurology. Here is discussed the birth of neurological sciences in the 19th and 20th century and their epistemological origins.

Discussion: In the span of two hundred years, we saw the emergence of two different brains: the neuroanatomical brain, exemplified by cortical localization and the anatomo-clinical approach pioneered by Jean-Martin Charcot, and the neurophysiological brain, exemplified by Santiago Ramon y Cajal’s neuron doctrine and pre-modern electrophysiology. We can distinguish between brain function, understood as the attribution of physiological functions to discrete anatomical structures, and brain functioning, understood as an approach to nervous system functioning and physiology that emphasizes mechanisms.

Conclusion:   In the 19th and 20th century, the brain became an organ with a physiology that could be understood. However, we saw the development of two different conceptions of the brain, which continue to influence neurological sciences to this day.

Relevance: With modern cognitive neuroscience, functional neuroanatomy, cellular and molecular neurophysiology and neural networks, neurological sciences all have different analytical units, which are tributaries of the 19th and 20th century development of the neuroanatomical and neurophysiological brains.

References

  1. Finger S. Minds behind the brain : a history of the pioneers and their discoveries. Oxford ; New York: Oxford University Press; 2000. xii, 364 p. p.
  2. Finger S. Origins of neuroscience : a history of explorations into brain function. New York: Oxford University Press; 1994. xvii, 462 p. p.
  3. Willis T, Feindel W, Pordage S. The anatomy of the brain and nerves. 2014.
  4. Keynes G. THE HISTORY OF MYASTHENIA GRAVIS. Med Hist Medical History. 1961;5(04):313-26.
  5. Lennox WG. THOMAS WILLIS ON NARCOLEPSY. Arch NeurPsych Archives of Neurology And Psychiatry. 1939;41(2):348.
  6. Ackerknecht EH, Vallois HV. Franz Joseph Gall, inventor of phrenology and his collection. Madison: Dept. of History of Medicine, Univ. of Wisconsin Medical School; 1956.
  7. Temkin O. Gall and the phrenological movement. Bulletin of the history of medicine. 1947;21(3).
  8. Jefferson G. Selected papers. [London: Pitman; 1960.
  9. Flourens P. Recherches expÈrimentales sur les propriÈtÈs et les fonctions du systËme nerveux dans les animaux vertÈbrÈs. 1842.
  10. Flourens P. Examen de la phrÈnologie. 1851.
  11. Bouillaud J-B. Recherches expérimentales sur les fonctions du cerveau en général, et sur celles de sa portion antérieure en particulier. J Heb Méd. 1830;6:527-70.
  12. Aubertin E. Sur le volume et la forme du cerveau. Bull Soc Anthropol. 1861;2.
  13. Broca P. Remarques sur le siége de la faculté du langage articulé; suivies d'une observation d'aphémie (perte de la parole). Bulletins de la Société Anatomique. 1861;6:330-57, 98-407.
  14. Berker EA, Berker AH, Smith A. Translation of Broca's 1865 report. Localization of speech in the third left frontal convolution. Archives of neurology. 1986;43(10):1065-72.
  15. Jackson JH. Hemispheral coordination. Medical times and Gazette. 1868;2:208-9.
  16. Jackson JH. Case of disease of the brain-left hemiplegia-mental affection. Medical times and Gazette. 1872;1:513-4.
  17. Jackson JH. A study of convulsions. London: Odell & Ives; 1870.
  18. Ferrier D. The Localization of Function in the Brain. [Abstract]. procroyasocilon3 Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. 1873;22:228-32.
  19. Ferrier D. The functions of the brain. 2011.
  20. Ferrier D. The localisation of cerebral disease; being the Gulstonian lectures of the Royal College of Physicians for 1878. London: Smith, Elder; 1878.
  21. Goetz CG. Visual art in the neurologic career of Jean-Martin Charcot. Archives of neurology. 1991;48(4):421-5.
  22. Charcot J-M. Sclérose du cordons lateraux del la moelle épiniere chez une femme hysterique atteinte de contracture permanente des quatres membres. Bull de la Société Méed des Hôpit de Paris. 1865;2:24-35.
  23. Charcot J-M, Joffroy A. Deux cas d'atrophie musculaire progressive : avec lésions de la substance grise et des faisceaux antérolatÈraux de la moelle épinière. Archives de physiologie normale et pathologique. 1869:629-49.
  24. Godlee RJ, Bennett H. THE EXCISION OF A TUMOR FROM THE BRAIN. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease. 1885;12(2):247.
  25. Horsley V, Clarke RH. THE STRUCTURE AND FUNCTIONS OF THE CEREBELLUM EXAMINED BY A NEW METHOD. Brain Brain. 1908;31(1):45-124.
  26. Spiegel EA, Wycis HT, Marks M, Lee AJ. Stereotaxic Apparatus for Operations on the Human Brain. Science. 1947;106(2754):349-50.
  27. Charcot JM, Blin EdE, Charcot J, Colin H. Lecons du mardi ‡ la SalpÍtriËre. Paris: Claude Tchoud; 2002.
  28. His W. Die Neuroblasten und deren Entstehung im embryonalen Marke: Hirzel; 1890. 363 p.
  29. Kölliker A, Ebner V. Handbuch der Gewebelehre des Menschen. 6th ed. Leipzig: Engelmann; 1896.
  30. Finger S, Boller F, Tyler KL. History of neurology. Edinburgh ; New York: Elsevier; 2010. xviii, 952 p. p.
  31. Haller Av, Temkin O. A dissertation on the sensible and irritable parts of animals. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Press; 1936. 1 p., 49 p. p.
  32. Bell C, Shaw A. Reprint of the “Idea of a New Anatomy of the Brain,” with Letters, &c. Journal of Anatomy and Physiology. 1868;3(Pt 1):147-82.
  33. Magendie F. Expériences sur les fonctions des racines des nerfs rachidiens. Journal de Physiologie Expérimentale et Pathologie. 1822;2:276-9.
  34. Schwann T, Smith H, Schleiden MJ, Westleys & Clark, Sydenham Society. Microscopical researches into the accordance in the structure and growth of animals and plants. London: Printed for the Sydenham Society; 1847. xx, 268 p., 6 leaves of plates p.
  35. Ramón y Cajal S. Trabajos escogidos : (1880-1890). Barcelona: Antoni Bosch Editor; 2006.
  36. Charcot JM, Bourneville. Leçons sur les maladies du systËme nerveux faites à la Salpêtrière. Paris: A. Delahaye and E. Lecrosnier : Aux Bureaux du ProgrËs mÈdical; 1884.
  37. Sherrington CS, Grünbaum ASF. An address on localization in the 'motor' cerebral cortex. . BJM. 1901;2:1857-9.
  38. Sherrington CS, Grünbaum ASF. A discussion on the motor cortex as exemplified in the anthropoid apes. . BMJ. 1902;2:784–5.
  39. Sherrington CS. The integrative action of the nervous system. 2012.
  40. Sherrington CS. REFLEX INHIBITION AS A FACTOR IN THE CO-ORDINATION OF MOVEMENTS AND POSTURES. EPH Quarterly Journal of Experimental Physiology. 1913;6(3):251-310.
  41. Adrian ED, Matthews BHC. The interpretation of potential waves in the cortex. TJP The Journal of Physiology. 1934;81(4):440-71.
  42. Penfield W, Jasper HH. Epilepsy and the functional anatomy of the human brain. Boston: Little, Brown; 1954.
  43. Penfield W. No man alone : a neurosurgeon's life. Boston: Little, Brown; 1977.
  44. Feindel W, LeBlanc R. The wounded brain healed : the golden age of the Montreal Neurological Institute, 1934-1984. 2016.
  45. Penfield W, Erickson TC. Epilepsy and cerebral localization; a study of the mechanism, treatment and prevention of epileptic seizures. Springfield, Ill.; Baltimore, Md.: C.C. Thomas; 1941.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.